Temptations are America’s #1 cat deal with: they’re 100% nutritionally full and balanced for grownup upkeep and are available in many flavors

Our Review Process

Our critiques are based mostly on intensive analysis and, when doable, hands-on testing. Each time you make a purchase order by one in every of our independently-chosen hyperlinks, we’ll obtain a share of the proceeds. Read extra about how we’re supported right here.

Advertised as America’s #1 cat deal with, most Temptations cat treats are 100% nutritionally full and balanced for grownup upkeep. They are available in many flavors. Learn extra about this in style cat deal with in our unbiased overview.

The We’re All About Cats Standard – Rating Temptations On What Matters

We have analyzed Temptations cat treats and rated them in keeping with our requirements right here at We’re All About Cats. Our grades are based mostly on the species-appropriateness of the meals, the standard of the components, product selection, worth, buyer expertise, and recall historical past. You can learn extra about our scores right here.

Here are our scores for Temptations in these key areas:


  • Species-Appropriateness – 6/10
  • Ingredient Quality – 6/10
  • Product Variety – 8/10
  • Price – 8/10
  • Customer Experience – 7/10
  • Recall History – 8/10

Overall Score: 7.2/10

We give Temptations cat treats a 43 out of 60 score or a B grade.

About Temptations

Unlike most different pet treats, Temptations are 100% nutritionally full and balanced for grownup cat upkeep. They present all of the vitamins your cat wants within the quantities wanted. However, Temptations does advocate feeding your cat a well-balanced meal along with the treats. It’s simply good to know the treats are nutritious. You can provide them to your cat as a deal with, a meal, or as a cat meals topper.

Temptations are additionally the precise dimension to slot in treat-dispensing cat toys and watch your cat chase them round the home.

The “classic,” authentic Temptations treats are crunchy on the skin and delicate on the within. They additionally are available in creamy treats and delicate meaty bites. Temptations has all kinds of flavors.

If you’re questioning what number of Temptations treats you possibly can feed your cat, the product suggests that you could feed as much as 15 treats per 10 kilos (4.5 kg) of cat in a day as a deal with or snack. Each deal with accommodates fewer than 2 energy.

If you might be giving these treats as your cat’s principal meal, ¼ cup of Temptations treats can change ¼ cup of a cat meals resembling Whiskas Meaty Selections Food for Cats. Don’t overlook to offer contemporary consuming water in your cat always, together with if you find yourself giving your cat treats.

On the down aspect, Temptations has been in comparison with “kitty crack.” The recipes are created from tasty components (to cats) however they aren’t normally thought of the best high quality. You can anticipate components resembling hen by-product meal, floor corn, animal fats, wheat flour, and dried meat by-products. You won’t approve of those components however cats actually love Temptations. As lengthy as your cat isn’t allergic to any of those components, they in all probability received’t do any hurt, particularly if the treats are fed sparsely.

READ ALSO:  The Black Cat Mystique - Catster

Sourcing And Manufacturing

Temptations cat treats are made by Mars Petcare, a part of Mars, Incorporated. Mars is an American multinational meals processing, confectionery, and veterinary providers company. Mars has headquarters in McLean, Virginia, whereas Mars Petcare has headquarters in Franklin, Tennessee.

Mars Petcare has 85,000 associates/workers with areas on six continents. Mars operates some 22 factories within the United States, a number of vegetation in Canada, factories within the UK, together with operations in different nations.

As for sourcing components, Mars not too long ago introduced that it’s making progress towards procuring 100% of the fish it makes use of from extra sustainable sources.

According to the label and responses on Amazon.com, Temptations are made in Canada. However, we don’t now the place the entire components are sourced.

Has Temptations Cat Treats Been Recalled?

We didn’t discover any proof of Temptations having been recalled after a test of the U.S. Food & Drug Administration Database.

There was an accusation on Facebook in 2016 that Temptations had killed somebody’s cat however the firm responded and the publish was eliminated.

What Kinds Of Cat Treats Does Temptations Offer?

Temptations presents seven completely different sorts of treats on their web page: Classics, Creamy Purrrr-ée, Jumbo Stuff, Meaty Bites, MixUps, Seasonal, and ShakeUps. In further to a majority of these treats, the model presents a tremendous array of flavors: beef, hen, dairy, salmon, tuna, catnip, crab, lobster, shrimp, and turkey.

All collectively, we discovered 34 completely different sorts of Temptations treats on the model web page.

The hottest flavors are reported to be Tempting Tuna Flavor, Savory Salmon Flavor, MixUps Surfer’s Delight.

The highest rated treats (apart from the seasonal treats) had been the 6-Pack Variety Pack, the 6-Pack Feline Favorites, Crabby Crab Flavor, and ShakeUps Clucky Carnival.

Temptations Cat Treat Reviews

#1 Temptations Mixups Surfers’ Delight

View on Chewy View on Amazon

Temptations MixUps Surfer’s Delight treats is without doubt one of the hottest flavors made by Temptations. Like different Temptations treats, these snacks are crunchy on the skin and delicate inside. And, these treats are full and balanced for upkeep for grownup cats.

These treats have tuna, shrimp, and salmon flavors.

Here are the components (within the U.S., percentages aren’t normally offered): Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Brewers’ Rice, Wheat Flour, Dried Meat By-Products, Natural Flavors, Brewers’ Dried Yeast, Natural Tuna, Shrimp & Salmon Flavor, Dried Cheese

Some of those components may very well be thought of questionable. Ground corn and wheat flour, for instance, might be problematic, particularly in case your cat is allergic to corn or wheat. Animal fats is imprecise. It’s an unnamed fats. “Meat by-products” is one other imprecise ingredient from an unidentified supply. “Natural flavors” might be broth from the meat within the meals (maybe the hen by-product meal) however it’s additionally imprecise so there’s no strategy to know.

We did discover the pure tuna. If you’re unfamiliar with pure tuna, it’s prime quality tuna fillets caught with conventional fishing strategies. It helps maintain the oceans and sea life secure. It’s one thing that Mars has been dedicated to doing. The pure tuna shouldn’t be an enormous ingredient on this meals however it’s nonetheless noteworthy.

READ ALSO:  Why Do Cats Chatter Their Teeth?

Chicken by-product meal could be a good ingredient that includes lungs, liver, and kidneys. These are components that your cat would like to eat. They are excessive in protein and simple to digest.

The treats are a mixture of components, a few of which you won’t like. On the opposite hand, these are cheap treats. They are a enjoyable, tasty meals for cats so you possibly can’t complain an excessive amount of in regards to the components, particularly when cats love them a lot.

As for the dietary values, these treats have crude protein 28 %, crude fats 21 %, crude fiber 4.5 %, and moisture 10 %.

We can convert these figures into the dry matter foundation for the meals. This means eradicating the water from the figures to see what stays. If we do that we discover that the meals accommodates 31.1 % protein, 23.3 % fats, 5 % fiber, and 31.7 % carbohydrates (estimated).

This meals accommodates (calculated) 368 kcal per cup.


Composition: Chicken By-Product Meal, Ground Corn, Animal Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Brewers’ Rice, Wheat Flour, Dried Meat By-Products, Natural Flavors, Brewers’ Dried Yeast, Natural Tuna, Shrimp & Salmon Flavor, Dried Cheese

Nutritional Composition: Potassium Chloride, Choline Chloride, Salt, Taurine, DL-Methionine, Calcium Carbonate, DL-Alpha Tocopherol Acetate (supply of Vitamin E), Zinc Sulfate, Red #40, Mixed Tocopherols (preservative), Copper Sulfate, Vitamin A Acetate, Niacin Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Manganese Sulfate, Thiamine Mononitrate, D-Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Potassium Iodide, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Vitamin B6), Folic Acid

Guaranteed Analysis


Crude Protein: 28%

Crude Fat: 21%

Crude Fiber: 4.5%

Moisture: 10%

Dry Matter Basis


Protein: 31.11%

Fat: 23.33%

Fiber: 5%

Carbs: 40.56%

Caloric Weight Basis


Protein: 24.24%

Fat: 44.16%

Carbs: 31.6%

  • Ingredients We Liked: Natural tuna, Chicken by-product meal, dried cheese
  • Ingredients We Didn’t Like: Unnamed animal fats, meat by-products, Red #40 (a dye)
  • Common Allergens: Wheat flour, floor corn, fish (tuna; shrimp and salmon taste), hen by-product meal


  • Temptations treats are solely 2 energy per deal with
  • They are available in over 30 completely different flavors
  • The treats can present full and balanced diet for an grownup canine’s upkeep food plan


  • Some components are imprecise and unnamed
  • Most of the treats comprise corn and/or wheat flour

What Do Customers Think Of Temptations Cat Treats?

There are actually hundreds of constructive critiques on-line about Temptations cat treats. People and their cats love these treats. Of course, there are some unfavorable critiques however most individuals report that cats are loopy for these treats.

Positive Reviews

Kitty Crack
My cat is hooked on the entire temptations flavors. He talks to us till we give in. If we run out he’ll get depressed and stare at us. You’ve created a monster…lol – Tigerlilymom

Uh oh! Look out!
I’ve purchased approx. 6 completely different kinds of Temptations. My cats go nuts after they see me attain for this one! They put their entrance toes on the wall and paw at my hand – typically grabbing my hand to tug it all the way down to their mouths – to tug my hand down with one in every of these, apparently tasty, morsels! Definitely will get an A+ from my felines! – By Chris on Aug 17, 2021

READ ALSO:  Bone Broth For Cats: What You Need To Know

Negative Reviews

I’ve two tabby cats 5 years previous. My cats aren’t picker eaters by any means however they significantly strayed away from any treats from this model. Definitely do NOT advocate. – giannac15

cutcorner rubbish
I don’t know what’s mistaken with these deal with currently. I’ve been shopping for them for 3+ years and all of the sudden my cats will hardly contact them. They choose by them. I drop round 30 on a plate for every cat and every cat eats round 6-10 of them if that. So yeah, 20 or so are left they usually received’t contact them. I add extra treats and those left beforehand are nonetheless there together with a lot of the new ones I gave them. Whatever you guys modified -FIX IT. I’m not going to purchase cat treats which can be largely inedible. Either GO BACK TO THE FORMULA YOU USED TO USE OR I AND 1000S OF CAT OWNERS ARE SURELY DONE WITH YOU. TAKE YOUR PICK. My cats used to eat EACH AND EVERY TREAT. If I don’t see my cats consuming them -ALL- once more I’ll declare that you just’re infusing these “treats” with rubbish. STOP CUTTING CORNERS. YOU CHARGE AN ARM AND A TOE AS IS. ——- actually, actually, actually dissatisfied buyer – By cutcorneRgarbage on Sep 11, 2021

How Much Do Temptations Cat Treats Cost?

Temptations are cheap. A 3-ounce bag of treats is lower than $2. A 16-ounce tub prices just a little over $8. This is a well-liked worth dimension. Customers additionally just like the resealable tub for storing treats. The 30-ounce tub for about $16 can also be in style.

If you might be shopping for on-line, do test round to check transport prices. Some websites cost extra for transport than others.

Overall, Are Temptations Cat Treats A Good Choice?

Temptations are in all probability not the healthiest deal with you should buy in your cat however they’re the most well-liked cat deal with within the United States. Cats actually do love them. They do comprise some components that you just may choose they didn’t comprise however all of us eat junk meals as a result of it tastes good. So does your cat.

If your cat likes Temptations, it’s in all probability a good suggestion to shut your eyes and let him take pleasure in them sparsely.

How Do You Order Temptations Cat Treats?

If you’re within the United States or Canada, Temptations are simple to search out in shops and on-line. If you’re ordering on-line you possibly can test Amazon.com or Chewy.com.

In the UK, they’re offered on Amazon.com.uk and pet provide websites. They are additionally offered by the Whiskas web page since Mars owns Whiskas.

Click Here To Buy Temptations Cat Treats on Chewy


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here